That Popular Podcast
What makes everyone like him so easily? Why does she bug me so much? Why are they so weird? Why do I always do that? Why do I always let that person make me feel that way?
Aaron is a multi-award winning radio host and Mitch is a psych professor, previously the Chief Science Officer for the American Psychological Association. Together, they talk about the social stuff we all experience, why it happens, and what it tells us about ourselves. It's light, interesting, and fun. It's That Popular Podcast.
That Popular Podcast
That Way You Still See Yourself vs. How Everyone Else Sees You
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
How old are you vs. how old do you feel inside? What do you look like vs. what do you think you look like? Are you interacting with people based on the person you are today, or based on the version of you that only still exists in your mind’s eye?
It's That Popular Podcast. Mitch Princetine is a psychology professor at UNC Chapel Hill and the former Chief Science Officer at the American Psychological Association. Aaron Keck is a political scientist and award-winning radio host. Together, they discuss the popular and not so popular quirks of human behavior. Welcome into That Popular Podcast. Now, here's Mitch and Aaron.
SPEAKER_01I am coming to you today, a free parent. A free man. Oh wow.
SPEAKER_02Is there a difference between a free parent and a free man? Like does one just imply the other?
SPEAKER_01I mean, I am so dedicated to my kids. I am so dedicated to my family. But I have to admit, like, you know, it has been, it's been really interesting to like notice that when they're away, it's like, wow, uh it's just been so many years, or sometimes such a long time, since like there's nothing like it just on the way, on the way out the door just now, I was saying to my wife, like, okay, so who's doing pickup and we're like, oh, right, they're gone. They're on field trips. Like, that's it. Like, I don't know what to do with myself anymore. So, but I think one of the things back at school, you mean? Well, they're on field trips. They both have field trips for the next 48 hours, and I dropped them off this morning. Oh, wow. So when I got home, it was like me, my wife, the dog.
SPEAKER_02And nothing else.
SPEAKER_01And that's it. And I'm like, and the dog takes quite a lot of time, I have to say. But like, but just the whole like, wow, I've got like nothing to coordinate, no pickups, no, like, I'm basically a professional Uber driver at this point, is like my parent role, but like, no pickups, no, like who's gonna be freaking about their homework. Anyway, all this is super salient because I was having a conversation with my son just yesterday, and I swear that kid is growing every single day. I was talking with him, and we were eye to eye. And I actually looked down, I'm like, are you wearing some sort of tall shoes? No, he was not.
SPEAKER_02No.
SPEAKER_01In fact, I was wearing like slippers or something that probably gave me half an inch. And I was just thinking about it.
SPEAKER_02Exactly.
SPEAKER_01And I was like, What? But it just, it's so funny. Like, it just made me realize when talking with him, especially at this point, like, what would it have been like to be 14 years old and be, you know, I mean, I'm still a little bit taller than him, but he's probably five eight now. So I've only got like an inch or two, you know, more than him. What would it have been like to be 14 years old and ninth grader and be the height of someone that people wouldn't do a double take and be like, what? What's going on? You're oddly short. Because for me, and I think like I think we all do it, but I am still in my head who I was when I was 14.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I am not the person, I I am not what everyone might think of me today if I just walked down the street. I'm like, no, in my mind, I am still four foot eight, which I was when I was fourteen. I looked like I was nine years old. Like, what about you? Like what?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So we've talked about this. We did a we did an episode on on the impact of height. Of height. You were talking about that. And I said then, and this is still the case, like, I could not tell you right now off the top of my head how tall I was in ninth, tenth, eleventh grade. Okay. Because I wasn't abnormally short or abnormally tall. I was in the normal range somewhere. So it didn't really matter to me what my specific height was. What I remember is being fat. When I was, and like you look at me today, people look at me today and they go, Oh, you're skinny.
SPEAKER_01I would never in a million years have thought that you have ever had one pound more than normal, normal sized body shape. Like, you know.
SPEAKER_02I am in my 40s, and this was really only like a four-year period, four or five year period. Actually, not even five, four-year period in my life. Which four years. Uh I started in it started in like third into fourth grade. And by the time I was in eighth grade, I was already like starting to get taller. Like I hit my growth spurt in eighth and ninth grade, and I didn't gain any weight in that time. So I went from being fat in seventh grade to being skinny in ninth grade. So it's really four years out of a life that is much, much longer than that.
SPEAKER_01Wait, so 10 years of nothing notable about your weight. Yep. And then since then, another 30 some odd years of nothing notable about your weight. But this four-year period from fourth to eighth grade, uh, were you were you slightly heavy? Were you husky? What was the I think husky would have been the would have been the term.
SPEAKER_02So today, if I'm going to buy pants, I'm buying like anywhere from 30 to 32 inch ways. Okay. Grade 36. Oh my god, okay. Yeah, so I was like, I was quite heavy for a couple of years, but only a couple of years. And in spite of the fact that it was only a couple of years, when I look in the mirror, I'm fat. Really? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Oh my gosh.
SPEAKER_02I still think of myself that way.
SPEAKER_01It's isn't that so so it's interesting that it was those years. Like, so was it because there's something about those years in life, fourth through eighth grade, or was there just really, you know, significant teasing or something that just really stuck with you? Or like what do you think made those it was only four years, it was only four years stick so much.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I was not a popular kid in like elementary and middle school, and being heavy contributed to that. It was insult to injury a little bit.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, okay. But I mean, it's so interesting. I when my kids got, you know, Barnabat Mitzfood, it made me like go and look at my old pictures of when I was Barn Bot Mitzved. Right. And when I was Barn Mitsfit. And um, and when I was great. No, I was not both. Yeah. And um and I was looking at the pictures and I remembered what it was like being 13. But looking back at the pictures, I was shocked that it was even worse than I remembered. I was so much smaller and so much younger looking than all the other kids. I mean, honestly, I get why adults used to think that I was not in that peer group. You know, I mean, looking at the photos, I was like, wow, this is kind of very, very significant. How much, not just shorter, but just younger and thinner. And just I really looked like their younger siblings. Right. And I don't know, there's something like, I mean, I am in a decade beyond my 40s. I'm not gonna, I don't like saying it. It's the age that shall not be names. But I swear in my head, I still feel like when I'm starting with people my age or even people younger than me, I'm like, oh, I'm kind of like the little brother guy. I'm like the one that's younger, I'm the one that's, you know, I'm not quite as like gonna be seen as a grown-up as everyone else. Like, and it's so weird, but there was, but it was so ingrained in every day of my, especially at that like eighth grade time.
SPEAKER_02Interesting. Yeah. Do you think that you were treated differently by your peers for that reason? Or do you think you were perceived or a thousand percent, a thousand percent.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I might have told the story before, forgive me, but it was even very weird when two years after, because I like I was just starting to get taller in like college and you know, late high school. I so when you grow up on Long Island, they park a bus outside of the high school graduation, and they just drive you to the Upper East Side, and you all get apartments on the 80th between second and third. And like my entire high school essentially just lived there throughout, like, you know, um, everyone's 20s. And I was hanging out with some high school friends, and I ran into somebody um from high school, and they literally said, Hey, has anyone heard from Mitch Princeton recently? What, you know, what's he doing? And my friends like pivoted on their heel towards me and pointed, they're like, he's standing right in front of you. And they were like, No, what wait, what? And that's how significant and different and weird it was when I was a kid, and how different it looks, I look, I guess now, you know. But it was a big thing. And I read some research that like really resonated with me on this point because they did a study where they were looking at um, they were using eye tracking device and they were looking at how much you're perceiving your environment. And they did this by kind of watching movies of, you know, teen interactions, not like John Hughes movies, but like, you know, just general videos of like kids interacting with each other. And what they were really surprised about is when they were looking at also brain scans, is that the hippocampus was being pulled in and activated way more than anyone ever expected. Because if you're not familiar with the hippocampus, that's where we, I believe, have most long-term memories.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_01So it's kind of like why, when I'm perceiving someone walking across the street today, do I need to rely on long-term memories? Like it's not like I've been in a cave and not seen anybody on a street or a traffic light for all that time. But the researchers were kind of concluding that there's something about those long-term memories. And to be fair, when you are just starting to go through puberty, you're kind of building your adult brain, you know, so it's those memories that are gonna be the ones that are like now in your newly organized brain, that there's some sort of like reference point. And we are constantly pulling back to that reference point because everything we see is like, how does this fit with my whole worldview schema based on memories? And what memories are the most likely ones we're gonna use as our template? It's gonna be the ones that we first developed with our adult brains. So if you started growing up and having your growth spurt at eighth, ninth grade, seventh, eighth grade, that makes sense. For me, it was, you know, I'm still waiting for my growth spurt, but like, you know, but but me it was much later, but those are the memories that are maybe the ones that I'm pulling out of the hippocampus and comparing everything to still.
SPEAKER_02Because this is, I mean, this has been a running thread throughout a lot of the conversations that we've had on this show, which is that so much of our mental state, our psyche, our way of looking at the world, our worldview, and the extent to which all of those things affect our day-to-day, like the amount of money we make, our physical health, things like that can all be traced back to where we were when we were 10, 11, 12, 13. Like there's something about that period that's just like so important and impactful.
SPEAKER_01You know what? I wrote the book, I started the last chapter.
SPEAKER_02The book is called popular, by the way.
SPEAKER_01No, I'm not plugging it. All right, thank you very much. But all right, well, that's very nice. But people need to know that the book is. Thank you. But um, no, no, no. But when I wrote the book, I the started the last chapter talking about a pretty humiliating kind of peer victimization memory that happened to me when I was working at a grocery store. And I was so much smaller and younger. And like people would literally, I worked at the courtesy desk. Remember that at the grocery store, and like people would come up to me and be like, Are you gifted? And I'm like, uh, and they're like, No, are you like 12 and gifted? And like Doogie Howers was a thing back then. I'm like, no, no, I'm stupid and 17. I just look really young. Like, but it was that notable. And you know, and there were, you know, I was I was teased at the time and I put that in there. And one reporter, when doing like the media, you know, kind of book tour thing, um, said to me, They're like, Why did you put that into the book? Like, that's kind of an embarrassing story. And I said, you know why? Because I think that I really think that what we don't do enough of is confront what was it really like for me when I was in eighth grade. I mean, remember the parts that are hard because we try to push those away. And the reason why I think it's important to remember those hard moments is because I think that's still a part of who we are today. And I think if we don't we don't confront it, we don't recognize it, then we don't understand why do I get so, I don't know, hotheaded in that situation, or why do I get so nervous in this situation, or why do I act so weirdly in that context? And it I I bet you that it has a lot to do with the fact that you're still seeing yourself as the person you were when you were in eighth grade, and that is it is playing out again. So if we don't think about it, talk about it, recognize that that was a big part of who we still are, that part of our hippocampus is still activating a hundred times a day, then we're just gonna repeat patterns over and over again, right?
SPEAKER_02So this is in real time changing, slightly changing a very hard and fast belief that I have had for a while. Okay. And I think I've said this on this show, but if I haven't, I'll just say it again. Some people don't believe in God, some people don't believe in Santa Claus, I don't believe in adults. I don't think adults exist. I think we're all just big kids pretending. And no one ever hands you your adult brain. You just like get better and better at pretending, hopefully, over the course of time, but ultimately we're all just kids running around desperately hoping that no one notices that we're still kids. Based on what you're saying, that's not quite true. We do get handed an adult brain, but it's not an adult brain, it's a teen brain. We're all teenagers running around.
SPEAKER_01I think that's exactly right. I think that we still see the world through teen eyes. I mean, what was I just reading? Someone who was, you know, in their 80s, maybe, and they were saying, and people are asking them, like, oh my God, you're 80. How are you? You know, and they're like, I still feel 18. Like, you know, I really think, and this neuroscience research is so fascinating to me because it makes sense. If you are constantly at a subcortical level, and by that I mean it's that's not the thinking brain, it's not the conscious brain, it's the part of the brain below the cortex that's and where the hippocampus is if you're using that to affect what you perceive, how you react, whether your fight or flight is going to activate, whether you have an emotional, all of that is happening without you having to think about it. It's automatic. Like you're walking across the street, someone makes a face at you, you have this emotional response. That's all happening based on circuitry that was laid down in the brain when you were in eighth grade, ninth grade. And so we are still having these eighth, ninth grade reactions to lots of things at the neural level.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Okay, so three things. Let's see if I can remember all three of them. Number one, you mentioned let's confront the bad stuff that happened to us in seventh, eighth, ninth grade. Uh, do you think the bad stuff is more impactful on us long term than the good stuff that happened in seventh, eighth, and ninth grade? Or do we just not confront that at all?
SPEAKER_01I'm Jewish, of course. I focus on the bad stuff. What are you even saying? What's the point of talking about the good stuff?
SPEAKER_02I'm Protestant. There's nothing but bad stuff. I got into Buddhism. That's even more there's nothing but bad stuff.
SPEAKER_01No, I mean, it probably is a good idea to focus on the good stuff. Someone will have to remind me what those good things are. But yeah, I I I tend to live more in the oh yeah, the guilt and the shame and uh one one tragedy after another. But um but yeah, I mean, I do think also it would be better, but I we don't have as dramatic emotions to the good stuff. And, you know, fear and anger run still deep. So I do think that for survival reasons alone, we are really primed to pay attention and to the brain's motivational kind of network to say, whoa, do something quick, alert when when you have a threat. So I I do suspect that the bad stuff is a little bit more important. That was number one.
SPEAKER_02Someone said, uh someone, I think it was in like a guide to parenting, which I don't know why I was reading that. I don't have kids, but uh yeah, for funsies, uh, that I was reading said something that really stuck with me, which is that if you're like if you're a four-year-old kid and like just on an ordinary evening, you're just sitting there quietly playing while your parents are like watching TV or whatever. For four hours you could be doing that and everything's fine. But if you like break a lamp, then the parents yell at you, and while probably only for like 30 seconds, but that's what you're gonna remember from that evening. You're not gonna remember the four hours of everything was totally fine.
SPEAKER_01And that's which interestingly is why for child psychology for therapy, we are often teaching parents look at your ratio of praise versus negative, and maybe every once in a while just throwing out, hey, good job playing on your own there, just to try and level that balance. But anyway, that's a whole different thing.
SPEAKER_02So, number two, if we are kind of stuck in our teenage mindsets, is there anything that we can do to like jostle ourselves out of it? Like maybe try to think about looking at the world a different way than our 12-year-old brains have hardwired us to do.
SPEAKER_01I think we need people that we trust around us to, you know, help us see the world through a different pair of lenses sometimes. And sometimes that might be really confiding and being like, I don't know, there was something about that interaction. I just felt that they were looking down on me. I felt that they were kind of judging me. And, you know, sometimes you'll have someone in your life they'll say, yeah, I I see where you're coming from, but I honestly didn't think they meant meant it that way, and be like, hmm, okay, maybe that was like 16-year-old me that was seeing it that way. I trust so much this other person's perception that I'm willing to entertain the possibility that that was not an accurate take on what just happened. And there are times, like every time I look in the mirror and see how old and decrepit I am, that I'm like, holy crap, I'm not 16. Like, you know, and there are those wake-up calls. I just think that we we don't do enough of that. But I think if you're about to do like a presentation or meet somebody, or in your you're in a situation where you might be particularly vulnerable, it might be good to remember like the part of me that is activated when I'm feeling these emotions is probably not the part of me that anyone else has seen. That all exists in my memory at this point.
SPEAKER_02Man. Okay. And then the third thing is and getting back to how we started this conversation, which is you're you're a free parent, you're a free man for these couple of days, but your kids are going to be back soon. I I'm hearing this, and we've had similar conversations and on previous episodes, and I constantly like find myself thinking about and empathizing with people who are parents or caregivers or guardians of kids who are that age. Because if you are in charge of a kid who's 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, like that's the pivotal period, which means the pressure's on you to be on your game because that's the period when their psyches are being shaped in ways that are going to affect them profoundly for the next 40, 50, 60, 70, 80, 90. Our uh consciousness is gonna get uploaded in the cloud 400 years. Of course. So if you so what's your advice to parents, like of kids of that age? Like, how do you how do you navigate then?
SPEAKER_01Don't put your lenses on your kids. Okay. You are seeing the world through a way that made sense for you at that time when you were 16, given what you looked like or thought, or what your standing was in your school when you were 16. That may be the same. Oh my God, there are people whose kids I'm like, you are this is a cloning situation. I'm not even sure. There were two parents involved in this kid. You're so, so similar. And maybe there are things that are like it's really useful because I also looked like you, or I also was your height or size or whatever. But in a lot of cases, it's not. And the world has changed. And I think we'd have to be a little bit careful at am I reacting to something that my kid is saying, doing, thinking, or in at risk of because of something that's true for their situation, or because that would have been true in my situation. And I think it's actually uh okay to talk with teens about that in a pretty transparent way and be like, listen, for me, I I had a different experience than you did, and this is what that looked like. And I would have been scared in this situation, or I would have felt really worried about this. Like, but what about for you? And sometimes be like, oh my God, thank God you said it. That's exactly how I feel, and you could have a great. But sometimes we really learn from our kids, like, no, kids don't do that anymore. Like, in fact, I feel pretty good about that and be like, oh my God, great. Because I could have just given you a whole complex about something that you wouldn't have had to really apply in your life. So I do think we have to be sensitive to that. And obviously, some things are heritable, some things are still the same issue, but it's more check in, inquire. Is it the same for you? Is it not? Let me share what my feelings were and let you guide your interpretations of this guide, how we handle it.
SPEAKER_02And I guess that conversation would be good for kids as well, right? Because then that's that's showing them that there are other ways of seeing the world and other ways of looking at things. It's not fixed in this way.
SPEAKER_01It's great for kids. You know, one of the you do you remember, like, I don't know if this happened for you, but I remember someone coming in when they were when I was in kindergarten and it was a dentist, and they came in and they um made us chew on a tablet and brush our teeth. And then wherever we had not brushed our teeth, like it our teeth turned red. And in like five minutes, they gave us a demonstration to be like, look, see how important it is to brush for a full three minutes or whatever. And it was a little demonstration. It stuck with me for over 50 years now.
SPEAKER_02Oh man, that is a great demonstration. And I don't remember that at all. Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Okay, a lot of people in the Northeast, like uh growing up, like this was a big thing. Well, anyway, I bring it up because I often say, Why aren't psychology people not going into kindergartens and teaching? And they're like, Well, what would you teach? And you know, those little pictures that don't ask me follow-up questions.
SPEAKER_02I just want psychologists teaching kindergarten classes.
SPEAKER_01And I'm like, but you could do a little 15-minute demonstration that I think would similarly have an impact. They're like, like what? So I was like, all right, I better try it myself. So I went in to my kids' school when they were kindergartners, and I'm like, great, I got 15 minutes. What can I do? And what I did is I showed them those pictures. You know the one that it's like a hand drawing, and it either looks like an old lady wearing a scarf or it looks like a young woman plucking off of a big thing. There's another one where it's like it's either a duck or something. A rabbit. A rabbit.
SPEAKER_02Like and I basically There's a beer called Duck Rabbit, and it's modeled after that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I went in and I said to them, I go, Do you think you know what this is? Don't say it. Are you positive of what it is? Are you sure that that's definitely the right interpretation of what this picture is? Yes, yes, yes. Okay, now talk to the person sitting next to you. What do they think it is? And it was a quick lesson on we can have very certain assumptions of what we think something is in the world, and someone else can have a completely different interpretation of the exact same thing, and you can both be right. And both of those interpretations are valid. And I and who knows, these kids will grow up and they'll all become, you know, um horribly distressed as a result of that demonstration, I fear. But but the hope and the goal was like if someone did a better job of this, of course, is that could we teach kids really early on that we all see the world through one lens? It'll probably the lens they have when they turn 16. But like, but it's valid, cool, okay, and good to talk out loud about. Maybe there are different lenses, and we should be constantly questioning is the way that I saw it reality, or is it just a biased way that I saw it?
SPEAKER_02Unfortunately, we all collectively had that conversation back in the uh is the dress blue or white? Oh my god, right. And the world has not gotten better since we all had that collective moment.
SPEAKER_01Oh, that's because it's blue and everyone else was wrong. It's a hundred percent blue.
SPEAKER_00This has been that popular podcast. Subscribe to us and find all our episodes wherever you get your podcasts, or visit us online at that popular podcast.com.