That Popular Podcast
What makes everyone like him so easily? Why does she bug me so much? Why are they so weird? Why do I always do that? Why do I always let that person make me feel that way?
Aaron is a multi-award winning radio host and Mitch is a psych professor, previously the Chief Science Officer for the American Psychological Association. Together, they talk about the social stuff we all experience, why it happens, and what it tells us about ourselves. It's light, interesting, and fun. It's That Popular Podcast.
That Popular Podcast
That Fat Talk
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Have you ever heard someone negatively talk about their body, and then expect you to do the same? Or maybe they talk about how old they look or how many ailments they have, and then you have to join in too? Why do we do that?
It's that popular podcast. Mitch Princeton is a psychology professor at UNC Chapel Hill and the former Chief Science Officer at the American Psychological Association. Aaron Keck is a political scientist and award-winning radio host. Together, they discuss the popular and not so popular quirks of human behavior. Welcome into that popular podcast. Now, here's Mitch and Aaron.
SPEAKER_03How's it going? I'm doing okay. How are you? I'm doing doing good. Did you get a haircut?
SPEAKER_01I did get a haircut. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03As a matter of fact. Does it look good? Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_01It does. I I don't know so much whether the woman who cuts my hair is cutting it or just performing some sort of sorcery to make it look like I actually have a full head of hair because it's it's not great. Actually, since I was probably in my late 20s, I'm like, what's happening here? And it's just thinner, thinner, thinner.
SPEAKER_03Oh no.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. Like I there's all kinds of things in the morning just to try and make it look like I have hair on top of my head.
SPEAKER_03Whatever sorcery is being done is working because I think of you as having a full head of hair.
SPEAKER_01So well, then it is working because yeah.
SPEAKER_03If that is a comb over, it isn't a it is a particularly good comb over.
SPEAKER_01I don't think it's quite okay.
SPEAKER_03I don't know what's going on, but I mean you, you're lucky, you have a full head of hair, you have no They always say that you inherit your maternal grandfather's hair. Like that's a common thing. I absolutely did not because my maternal grandfather was bald relatively early. I definitely inherited my dad's hair because this, like, this hair that I've got is the same color and texture. Like it's very it's a full head of hair, but it's very like each individual strand is very thin and fine. Yeah. And that's also my dad's hair. And I'm very excited about that because number one, my dad has not gone bald even now, and he's about to be 75, and he also did not even start to go really gray until he was in like his 60s.
SPEAKER_01So tell me more about the color because I have 70-year-olds helping me across the street.
SPEAKER_03Um and that's got nothing to do with the hair.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and you don't have a single gray hair.
SPEAKER_03Okay, so I do have a couple of gray hairs. Number one, I inherited my dad's hair, and his top of head hair stayed brown until he was in his 60s. His beard went white in like late 30s, early 40s. And I also got that. So whenever I let my beard grow out, it comes in white even now. Wow. Which is interesting because like full head of brown hair juxtaposed against a very white beard. I also do get it colored when I go to the when I go to the salon. And this is not a vanity thing, this was a pandemic thing. This was a I went a year without getting a haircut. So I looked like Grizzly Adams when I walked into the salon. And because people were trying to get backed against the walls. Oh, yeah, 100%. Yeah. And this was this was 2021. People were afraid of a lot. So to say that they were afraid of me was saying quite a quite a bit. But I I decided my hair's grown out this long. I'm gonna go to an actual salon and have it done by like an actual person as opposed to the $10 haircuts that I had usually gotten. And when I was in there, I was like, you know, I've always kind of wanted to have it dyed black. Like make it look like not that much of a difference, but a little tiny bit darker. Yeah. So I had them do it and it looked good. So now I just keep doing it. So now even if I now even if I go gray, no one will know. You you won't know. I won't know, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And tell me about the wrinkles, because I'm like a Sharpe here with all the, you know, my my face is kind of folded like an envelope. No wrinkles. Oh my god, no. I'm just how is this happening?
SPEAKER_03If you have lots of wrinkles, we need to cut off the psychology talk and you need to do the podcast thing of telling everyone about your skincare regimen because you've already said you need to go to the eye doctor, so I don't trust a word that you say. That's fair, but I'm wearing glasses. So these are new glasses, too. I can see real well. No, I've got a couple of wrinkles underneath my eyes, but that's it, which is good, which is good. I've also led a fairly easy life, which is probably helpful as far as that goes.
SPEAKER_01Uh-huh. And how about the the mid-40s beer gut? Oh, I've totally got that. No, you don't.
SPEAKER_03It's it's right, it's underneath this very loose-fitting shirt that I've got on. Okay. I'm skinny fat. I am one of those people that like I I am skinny, but I don't have like a lot of muscle. So yeah, I got love handles that need to go away, and I'm not 100% sure how to do it.
SPEAKER_01All right. I can't, I can't do this anymore. This is another little bit.
SPEAKER_03I realize this is going to be like a body shaming like breakdown every aspect.
SPEAKER_01This is another bit, and I can't do it. It's already so weird to talk about. But no, so there's this thing in psychology where well, actually, there's two things. And one of them is called fat talk.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_01And the other, which is so interesting, is called old talk. Let me start with fat talk. Like there's this thing where, and I have to say it's predominantly female, where women of all ages, mostly in adolescents, though, or young women, will stand in front of a mirror, like let's say in a changing room or something, and they will just comment on how horrible they look. And kind of the other person's response, the appropriate response is, oh, well, you, what are you talking about? It's me that looks so much worse. And they just go back and forth talking about how each one looks worse than the other one.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_01Why? Why are they this doesn't sound pleasant or fun at all to do?
SPEAKER_03This is the four Yorkshire men comedy bit where the four guys are sitting around talking about how poor they were growing up. Right, right. And trying to one-up each other as far as that goes. No, I mean, that's gotta be a cultural thing, right? I mean, every every adolescent woman in particular is just constantly hit with this barrage of highly unattainable body images. So 100%.
SPEAKER_01And this is definitely more of a Western phenomenon. So we don't see this in the literature happening as much in eastern samples. But why? So you would think in a world where the media and perhaps, you know, coming from a patriarchal, you know, kind of there's so much shaming about being heavy. I would I would love it if instead women were like, you know something? You look great. You have great legs. Oh yeah, well, you have great hips. And there was just nothing but talking about like boosting each other up. But it's so it's sad to me when you think about teen girls like sitting around at a hangout and just talking about, well, my flaws are so much worse than your flaws. It's like, no, yours are worse than mine, you know, and just it feels like that's making things worse rather than no, a hundred percent, a hundred percent.
SPEAKER_03And we do this as a way to like buck up the other person, like, oh, you're fine. Well, but we do it by running ourselves down as opposed to building them up.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's what's so interesting is that both people end up having more body dissatisfaction at the end of it. At the end of the conversation, boosting up is kind of not working, right? Clearly, right? But the extent to which it just highlights that, okay, it's totally normal for us to pick our own bodies apart, feel terrible about them, and somehow it's socially normative to do that side by side, back and forth for as long as we want to do this. And it's it's really it's really sad. Like I I obviously have never ever experienced what it's like for a woman in today's world to do any of this. So I don't understand it. I I genuinely would love to know more, but in the literature, what it's said is that it's not just among close friends, strangers will do this in a uh changing room, sure, as well as really close friends. It happens a lot, like a lot, and both women end up leaving feeling pretty bad about it. I should say it happens with men too. Most of the samples that have been looked at are predominantly heterosexual males, and it's tends to be more focused on like the lean muscularity, like, oh, your arms are enormous. I wish my arms were that big.
SPEAKER_03I was gonna say the male version would be muscle talk, right? Or like body tone talk. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01There's not as much of that among auto males because there is that like among like heterosexual males, like, well, I don't want to talk too much about your body because then that might feel somehow, right? You know, like there's a homophobia that kind of starts to mention. But but when it is discussed, it can be discussed. I've heard it when I'm at the gym sometimes. People like just like one or two comments, that's it. Not as long as it will happen among women, it seems.
SPEAKER_03So that's interesting because so what does the literature say about like why people do it? Like, what's the suggestion? Because at at the end of the day, I am on some level a functionalist. Like, I think if if everyone is doing something that it's gotta it's gotta like fill some need or serve some purpose. So why do people like gravitate towards that?
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell, so there's there's definitely some element of like, oh, I'm hoping that I get uh compliments like in here, you know, like, oh my god, my waist is hard and be like, you have a 12-inch waist. What are you talking about? Like, okay, okay. Yeah, you're right, I'm awesome. You know, like but I think there's also some like, I just want to commiserate and how bad it feels to be in my skin, and you feel just as bad. And we're we're having a moment of just it feels good to feel like you're not the only person in the world that feels that bad about how you look. You know, I get that. I think there's some element of that, but it's I don't as the father of a daughter, I wish this did not exist as a phenomenon. Like I do not want my daughter talking badly about her body, doing it socially, and I certainly don't want anyone pointing at, you know, encouraging her to do so because they've just done so, and now the social expectation is that she has to come up with some flash she thinks she has.
SPEAKER_03Because there are equivalents of this elsewhere, right? I'm I'm thinking of uh Amy Tan writes in the in the Joy Luck Club, the scene where the mother brings out this amazing meal and then immediately criticizes it because that's the that's the cultural norm. Like you criticize your own cooking, and then the expectation is kind of the reverse of what you're saying for everyone else at the table to say, no, no, it's great and compliment it, like you're fishing for complimentary.
SPEAKER_01Like a modesty and overly.
SPEAKER_03So there is like there is kind of a widespread thing of initiating a conversation by saying, Oh, I suck and here's why. Yeah. But then the reaction is usually, oh no, no, no, you're great and here's why. And what you're describing with fat talk is, oh no, no, no, you're not nearly as bad as me. Yeah. And that's the downward spiral.
SPEAKER_01It's like that we talked once before about like co-rumination, but I think it has an element of that, like, let's just together bury ourselves down the downward spiral. Let's just go down the downward spiral together of how bad it feels that this is a constant battle with our own bodies. And, you know, and and we feel constantly not good enough compared to what the ideal is that's always in our faces, you know, on every billboard out there. Say say more about when you've heard it would happen with men.
SPEAKER_03I cannot off the top of my head think of a specific instance of it happening with with men, like in my presence. So that speaks to like what you're saying about this being specifically like adolescent girls in particular, but but girls and women more generally. But I think if it's gonna happen with men, it's gonna happen in terms of like I'm not fit enough, I'm not muscular enough.
SPEAKER_01Like there is a little like I said, I there is a little bit of this at the gym. Sometimes if there are people that are like My job sucks.
SPEAKER_03That's that's part of it. Like my job sucks and I'm not fulfilled in my like work life. Yeah. Maybe that's maybe that's the version. Which is that with you get that from what you're doing. Interesting because then you're like both genders.
SPEAKER_01You're blaming like something external, like this other thing forced upon me is bad rather than I, my appearance, my own stimulus value in the world is bad.
SPEAKER_03Right. So I mean we also associate we also like equate our identity with our job. So by saying my job sucks, you're also saying my identity sucks.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's true.
SPEAKER_03So that's true. Like you think you've got a bad let me tell you about my day. Like that would be an equivalent.
SPEAKER_01But this is a very like this is a very classic Jewish thing, like oh, your neck, my back. Like, don't even start. Like, you know.
SPEAKER_03But so I was also trying to remember scenes from the nanny where this was the case or Seinfeld, but yeah.
SPEAKER_01So the fat talk literature has been out there for a while. Now there's old talk. Who's naming these? It's it's just been out there for a while, and researchers just kind of like start publishing under this, then it catches on. But old talk, like we were pretending to do, is yeah, just this kind of hyper focus on all of the things that make me feel old. And I'm gonna talk about my old things and say, no, but you don't look old at all. And then you're gonna be like, what are you talking about? I totally feel old also. And it's this and it's so funny because both of them are these very society, like we're supposed to be youthful, we're supposed to be fit, guys are supposed to be lean muscular, women are supposed to be impossibly thin, like that kind of thing.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So have you ever heard anyone do old talk?
SPEAKER_03Oh, I'm getting to that age. Yeah. No. It's it's very noticeable in my friend group where more and more and more, and we're all about the same age, like we're in our 40s at this point. Like more and more and more the conversation starts to turn to aches and pains, which is hilarious. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So I'm not on Facebook anymore, but for you know, years ago I was. And when I was on there, it was so interesting to me because I started seeing all these ads, right? Tons uh a long time ago, there were no ads or very few, but tons of ads, ten for every post. And the ads were all about beer belly and thinning hair. And I hadn't spent a lot of time thinking about those things before. But after seeing 10 ads a minute about it and seeing all these depictions of guys being like, my whole life sucks because I have thinning hair and you know, whatever, I was it starts to develop a complex. I'm like, wait, is it terrible that my hair is that like I didn't think that I would be the pariah of the community and I'd be stoned in the village square? But apparently that's what's happening to all these other guys in these ads. I there was oh, there was one a whole thing on skincare. And I was like, what? Really? Do I need to get a skin product? I don't know. I've never thought about my skin in my life. Like, but it's just amazing. Like, women must go through this constantly. This is my first experience of having society tell me, like, you're not good enough.
SPEAKER_03But I I will say that you have absolutely no reason to fear being shunned as a pariah or stoned in the public square. Quite the opposite. Men will want you to hang around with them more often so that they will look better by comparison.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01Thank you.
SPEAKER_03Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_01That's exactly the reassurance that I'm looking for. Yeah. No, it's no, it's so it's so interesting though, right? Like how much this becomes a thing. And then and then people probably go out and start noticing, like, wow, well, I've never noticed everyone else's skin. But now that I look, yeah, maybe I do have that. And then then it starts coming up in conversation. Like, this is so much stuff we're doing to ourselves.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Or advertisers can create a market opportunity if they make you feel bad enough about something that you previously didn't care about, then you're more willing to go buy their product.
SPEAKER_03100%. Yeah. Yeah. Screw them. And it's also, yeah, absolutely. And it's also the case that we're always going to be more capable of noticing our own flaws because number one, everybody who's depicted in advertising or some cultural form like TV or movies or music videos or anything else is going to be heavily made up or airbrushed or photoshopped or AI'd at this point to look perfect. So we're never going to we're never going to measure up to that. And when we look at our own faces in the mirror, we are way closer to the mirror, to our own faces reflection than we are to like the people we see on the street. So when we walk by someone on the street, we're not going to notice their pores and pock marks nearly as much as we'll notice our own when we're like looking at ourselves real up close in the mirror.
SPEAKER_01A hundred percent. And the team at the publisher was like, okay, we're sending you out for headshots. We're sending out yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yep. So it's called popular, by the way. It's really good, and y'all should have read it.
SPEAKER_01Ha, okay, thanks. But um, so I go out and I get the headshots, and I'm like, great. So are you gonna like just send me those photos today? Like right after we did the little photo shoot thing. It's like, no, no, no. I'm gonna take a few days to, you know, edit them. And I'm like, edit them? What are you why are you editing them?
SPEAKER_03Okay. So they're like, Tom Selleck.
SPEAKER_01Right. So I'm a little bit like, okay, so I get them and I was like, huh, can you also send me the originals alongside? And they go, oh yeah, we just did some editing for light distractors. Distractors, quote unquote. I'm like, so I look really carefully at these photos. Normally I have like a couple of Samsonites right under my eyes, like these big giant bags that are constantly there. And yes, we've we've reviewed the thinning and graying air.
SPEAKER_03Um I like how we call them Samsonites. I've never heard that before.
SPEAKER_01But but so they were gone. And I was like, wait a minute, I I can't erase these in real life. Now what do I do? Like these are distractors. Are they really that bad? Like you had to spend two days editing these photos just to make someone not want to throw my book across Barnes and Oval away from the cash register. Like it was so weird. But I was like, it must be really hard for the people you do see on TV because while this is nothing the same, I was not on TV in this way, but like, but just seeing that was like, oh my God, I'd never thought of these things as something that needed to be edited away. And I have to walk around like this every day. But you apparently thought that this needed to be fixed before it could be put on the back coder of a book. That does not feel good.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Especially when you're not a celebrity, right? Like you're not a you're not a TV star.
SPEAKER_01I want an unattractive book author. That means they spent more time on studies than anything else.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. Like you're in the library all the time because what else are you gonna do? Right.
SPEAKER_01We should all be like, you know, moldy and spiderweb swarming on us. Like, that's the sign of a good book author. You want a real studio's person.
SPEAKER_03I will say, getting back to the the functionalism question of like what purpose does all of this serve, I will say that this is reminding me doing uh talking about old talk and complaining about your aches and pains. Uh a few years ago, I've had the worst luck with getting like old people ailments early in life. Like I had shingles when I was 32, which hopefully never again. It was a small case or whatever, but like that happened. And then when I was 42, I had sciatica. Oh my god. I chalk up to being penance for having done improv for eight years and using sciatica as the go-to like ailment because it's just such a funny word. So now like the fates are bestowing it upon me. Yeah, like Zeus' lightning bolt. So I'm dealing with that for six weeks. But while I was dealing with that for six weeks and then talking about it for six weeks afterwards, people were coming out of the woodwork talking about how they had gone through the exact same thing. Yeah. And the fact that everyone else around me was saying, Oh, yeah, I went through that too, did make me feel better about having gone through that.
SPEAKER_01Or commiseration is a good thing. It does feel good for a little while. But I don't know. I just, you know what I wish? I wish that let's start with teen girls, but let's say that to the extent that this applies for, you know, if it's about lean muscularity or olds or whatever, but apparently most of it's fat talk and most of it's teen girls. So here's what I wish. I wish that the next time that teen girls are standing next to each other, whether it's in a changing room or at a sleepover or whatever, and someone says, Oh my god, my ankles. I wish that I had the thin ankle. You know, someone goes, Shut up. You look great. We're not doing this. This is making other people money. This is getting other be this is meeting norms that we had no intention of setting, you know, we had no part of setting. And let's do the opposite. Let's say you look great, I look great, we look different, but that doesn't matter. We're s we're both great in our own way. We're not doing this.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That would be amazing. If we just spent more time boosting each other up.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And it's partly on pop culture and advertisers and corporations to to encourage that. But at the end of the day, like girls gotta do it for themselves, right? Like people have to, like in that moment, in that room, like be willing to have the wherewithal to like step back and and buck each other up.
SPEAKER_01Stand up for each other. Yeah, exactly. Right. Yeah. Except for you. You should definitely keep dyeing your hair.
SPEAKER_03No, a hundred percent. Yeah. No, I'd we're we're absolutely agreed on that. I will say because we gotta we gotta wrap up. This is happening in comedy. You're familiar with the dozens, like uh this is something specifically in black culture, but it's you see it, you see it in other places, playing the dozens, like insulting each other and trying to one up the insult game. More and more you're seeing folks doing the opposite, playing the dozens, but doing it in compliment fashion as opposed to insult fashion. Good. Yeah. More of that, I think. I love it. It's less funny, but what are you gonna do?
SPEAKER_01I think it's a good idea.
SPEAKER_00This has been that popular podcast. Subscribe to us and find all our episodes wherever you get your podcasts, or visit us online at that popular podcast.com.