That Popular Podcast
What makes everyone like him so easily? Why does she bug me so much? Why are they so weird? Why do I always do that? Why do I always let that person make me feel that way?
Aaron is a multi-award winning radio host and Mitch is a psych professor, previously the Chief Science Officer for the American Psychological Association. Together, they talk about the social stuff we all experience, why it happens, and what it tells us about ourselves. It's light, interesting, and fun. It's That Popular Podcast.
That Popular Podcast
That “Tall Guy Energy”
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Guys size each other up - literally. Whether we realize it or not, guys are being influenced by one another’s height in subtle and some not so subtle ways. Do women have a version of this too?
It's That Popular Podcast. Mitch Prinstein is a psychology professor at UNC Chapel Hill and the former Chief Science Officer at the American Psychological Association. Aaron Keck is a political scientist and award-winning radio host. Together, they discuss the popular and not so popular quirks of human behavior. Welcome into that popular podcast. Now, here's Mitch and Aaron.
SPEAKER_02How are you doing? I'm good. I'm good. How have you been?
SPEAKER_01Good. The kids are away at camp, so my wife and I have been going out to dinner every night.
SPEAKER_02Sweet, beautiful freedom.
SPEAKER_01I mean, we really, really miss the kids so much, but it is unique for us to be able to have this much time. So we are checking out all the new restaurants in town and stuff like that. Actually, last night we just went to a new place. It was really good. And we were we were having this conversation because we had just come from an interaction where there were like a whole group of people, and there was somebody in the group that my wife and I were describing as having uh tall guy energy.
SPEAKER_02Oh God. What is tall guy energy?
SPEAKER_01Well, I can kind of imagine it in my head, but I mean, I mean, it's ironic to say because I'm 6'4, so you know. So it's it's rare that people are taller than me, but yeah, 100%.
SPEAKER_02But in this, in this case, we certainly never talked about being short on previous installments of this very show.
SPEAKER_01I've been 6'4 since the day I was born. Um and um no, but this is someone who probably is like 6'4. And you know, to be fair, like maybe this is someone that is just a little bit aloof, but there's something about there's something about their demeanor that was a little bit like, I'm in charge. I am the person who is the coolest at this table.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_01I know it, and I'm gonna make sure you all know it. And it's like, wow, we're we're like middle-aged. Like this is not stuff that usually happens, but there's definitely some like I'm used to walking in a room and being the the dominant person. I am the alpha in this room.
SPEAKER_02And right, and sometimes is he an alpha or is he an alpha wannabe? Because I feel like there's a difference.
SPEAKER_01He's kind of an alpha.
SPEAKER_02Like, I think So an actual alpha.
SPEAKER_01I think an actual well, he kind of makes sure he is. Like he's a little bit of the male Regina George. Like he's a little bit. Um he thinks that the comments that he makes are the coolest comments. He kind of feels like why bother talking to anybody that walks up to say hello, they should be more thrilled that they're talking to him. Of course, of course. That's not something you see a lot in adulthood, you know, but I do think, and let me be fair, like not all tall people do this, obviously, but but this was somebody who just it seemed to go with the persona. They were like, I am I am the coolest person in the room.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01And I know it, and I am going to make sure you all know it.
SPEAKER_02Interesting. Yeah, it is interesting because I am thinking like all of this reminds me of someone very specific that I know who is also tall.
SPEAKER_03Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_02And also we don't associate with this particular like person as much anymore than we used to, maybe like, I don't know, five, eight years ago, give or take. Pre-pandemic, post-pandemic, I've lost track of time. Right. But yeah, definitely, it definitely gave off that energy. I go back to alpha versus alpha wannabe because I do think that a true alpha, if such a thing exists, is not someone who exudes effort. Yeah. Someone who's like really walks in and really consciously wants to turn the room towards them is not actually an alpha. Yeah. Again, to the extent that such a thing exists. I don't know.
SPEAKER_01On the height thing, there's actually data on this.
SPEAKER_02I was gonna say you did like equate it with tall guy energy, which implies that there is at least like the stereotype of a correlation.
SPEAKER_01Some of this is a height thing, some of this is not. But like on the height thing, so I think there's been like actually Stefan Polisai, isn't the taller of the presidential candidates the winner more than 50% of the time?
SPEAKER_02Like clearly more than I don't know how James Madison snuck through, but they're well, they didn't have TVs.
SPEAKER_01That's true, yeah.
SPEAKER_02But but even pre-TV. Like it is, it was the case that it was the case pre-TV, and it is the case now post-TV that the taller presidential candidate of like the two major party candidates is the one that tends to win.
SPEAKER_01Not always, but something about well, here's the finding that I find so fascinating. There was a study done, 10,000 Brits, all men, and they were trying to look at quarterlets of their salary. And they were in their 30s, maybe 40s, and they looked at all the things you would expect, right? Like, you know, how many years of school and how well they did at their job and blah, blah, blah. And it turns out that their height was one of the strongest quarterlets of their salary.
SPEAKER_03Interesting.
SPEAKER_01But it wasn't their height in their 30s and 40s, it was how tall they were when they were 16.
SPEAKER_02Oh.
SPEAKER_01That predicted their salary in their 30s and their 40s.
SPEAKER_02What gives me confidence and charisma as a teenager that carries forward for the next 50 years of my life?
SPEAKER_01I mean, there's something about just that, like, I'm looked at as being a leader. I'm used to that. I I am someone that people defer to. I have the dominant energy in the room. I mean, I this stuff happens with every other species. So, like, it'd be silly to think that humans are totally immune to that.
SPEAKER_03Right, of course.
SPEAKER_01I do think on Zoom it was really interesting to talk with people for months and then later meet them and be like, oh, why have I been listening to you? You're much shorter than me. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02No, of course, but like your voice sounded so much taller. What is what happened to you?
SPEAKER_01But that was like this for shorter people, it was like this wonderful period of time of like, yay, everyone, my no one knows how short I am. But like, but it was a very it's very interesting that we kind of rely on that dynamic a little bit. Right. I don't know.
SPEAKER_02I that is interesting.
SPEAKER_01I was talking with my wife about this, and tell me, tell me what you think. But I think that there's this thing with males in particular that there's an unspoken dominance hierarchy in a lot of male interactions. I think that it's someone someone's talking about their jobs, someone's flauncing how much they make, someone is talking about. I mean, I go to the gym a lot, so clearly there. There's a whole lot of like how much you can lift. Like, but even like, I don't know, I just think that there's there's something where that is salient when you're in an interaction with a group of guys, that there's some posturing or discussion or something where someone's making clear that they are more or less dominant than everyone else.
SPEAKER_02That is interesting because again, like I'm thinking in my head and I'm running through my own personal rolodex of dudes I know. And there are a handful of dudes I know who are like that, and I tend not to try to associate with those people or hang out with them on a regular basis because it's just kind of exhausting, right? Like to deal with that. But that said, like, I don't have a problem shoving those people to the back of the Rolodex because there are lots and lots of guys in my life that are not like that. And I feel like I feel like it's just a matter of finding the right people, maybe. I don't know. I feel like maybe I've just been super lucky.
SPEAKER_01No, no, I think you're right. I mean, obviously, this is not this is not true for all guys, and this is not the way that all interactions happen. And, you know, I don't have a lot of interactions either where this feels like a major part of it, but I feel like if you're in a group of guys, there is some way in which the pecking order gets established without even anyone talking about it. Like it might be the kind of thing where someone's saying, Oh, well, I mean, I don't know. I mean, you would be the one that would know more about that than me. I mean, I'm I don't, I'm not as good at my job as you are at yours. Right, right. Or some element of like, even just like, have you noticed that if you're if you're walking through a door, someone will hold the door open and everyone else will walk through. And the person holding the door open is usually the larger of all the guys. Like, there's almost this element of like, well, I'm the one that will hold the door open for you.
SPEAKER_02So I am directing people through. Yeah, no, I get that. I get that.
SPEAKER_01Like, there's these little ways, like sometimes I'm in a crowd of people and someone's trying to get through the line, let's say, that I'm sitting in.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01There are a lot of people online. They can pick anyone to say, excuse me, and walk between.
SPEAKER_02Oh God, I hate this situation so much.
SPEAKER_01But and they'll never walk between the two very tall people or larger people, but as someone who's not as large, you know, like I'm it's so funny. And sometimes, because I'm totally a nerd psychologist, sometimes if I see someone heading, like I'll a little bit stand up straighter or like just a little bit like push back my shoulders just to be like, I wonder what's gonna happen. And can I tell you 100% of the time? Not that anyone's seen me do this, because that would but if I just make myself a little bit bigger, never am I the person that they cut through line on now.
SPEAKER_02Because I always feel in that situation that people are always cutting in front of me. And I always thought that it was because I gave the person in front of me a little bit more like personal space, thus creating an opening for people to zip through. Yeah. But maybe I just need better posture and I won't have that problem anymore. I don't know.
SPEAKER_01Something that we're not even attuned to consciously, or you know, but I know every other species does it where there's some element of like there's a pecking order, there's a hierarchy. Like, and I think as someone that's never been tall, well, sometimes in temple I feel tall, but like outside outside of being surrounded by other Jewish people, um uh I never have felt tall. Like I I see that happen all the time, and I just feel like in so many conversations, people are making this allusion to, oh, well, well, clearly you're you're really fit. I mean, no one's saying that to me, but I mean to other people, like you're really fit, or you're gonna be.
SPEAKER_02In this room, you are the fittest one.
SPEAKER_01I have discovered that when you go to the gym, you actually have to do something there, though. So all these years I'm like, I'm going to the gym. What's the problem? But there's that, I don't know, it's just it's always a thing. And the thing that's so interesting about it with guys and height is that the unspoken rule of that the unspoken dialogue about dominance can be as subtle as just standing next to somebody and them looking literally down at you.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_01It just and I don't think women do this at all. I don't think there's any element of dominance and hierarchies or high like I just don't think this is a salient factor in the same way that it is for guys.
SPEAKER_02I would be very surprised if, you know, I'm a guy, I'm gay, I don't know anything about women, but I'd be very surprised if that were like not the case at all. If something is the case with one sex or gender, it's gonna be like in some way, shape, or form the case with it. Like not the same, but there's some other there's some other form that it takes. I mean, would be my guess. I don't know.
SPEAKER_01I mean, when I turn to my wife, she's like, oh my god, this is like the secret life of men that just she's like, what guys think about this?
SPEAKER_02Because like it's but there's also a secret life of women, like there's things that women think about that guys do believe.
SPEAKER_01Totally. And it's it's probably not this, but I mean just the fact that women could put on four-inch heels or not, and that's not changing the dynamics dramatically, you know. Um I don't know. It's so all this is very salient because my son is just about to become taller than me. Ah, nice. So I am also like, oh god, it's happening. It's happening, yeah. Um, I mean, I I've still got a good two inches on him right now, but he's been away at camp. So by the time he gets back, like he will probably be. I already look at him kind of in the eye, and I'm like, this is just weird. It's so weird.
SPEAKER_02This is why you're enjoying his time away at camp so much because it's like your last hurrah.
SPEAKER_01I'm the tallest in the family still. It's great. The dog still prefers me.
SPEAKER_02Like when So I will I will ask you, uh, we're talking about people like being tall and feeling tall and like projecting tallness as a sense of dominance. I personally have always been like super average height. Like I'm five, nine. Brad, my husband, and I will often like play argue with each other over who's taller. He's like got three quarters of an inch on me. Yeah, okay. Uh, so he makes fun of me for that, which I guess feeds right into uh what you were saying. That said, I'm clearly the dominant one in that relationship, and we won't have any words about it otherwise. Uh, but like, but like getting back to that, like I don't because I've been super average height, I've never felt tall or short. So maybe I don't perceive like dominance hierarchy as much because I am mid as far as this goes.
SPEAKER_01Five nine is average height for Americans now.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. But I feel like five nine is maybe slightly below average, but it's close enough to being average. That it's like it's basically there.
SPEAKER_01I'm five nine and a half. Thank you very much. And um, and I so I know that that's that is like exactly the 50th percentile, but that's taking into account all race, ethnicity, and age.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_01Working on a college campus, I can tell you that five nine is way short.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And even in my 20 years on this campus and North Carolina, everyone that is here, these are all Western European immigrants. We have a lot of like Dutch and English folks that came to North Carolina.
SPEAKER_02The entire Norwegian soccer team.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like it's it's it's pretty short in that since I moved here, I used to be taller than almost every female in my class. And it is now pretty routine that the females are taller than me now. So it's changing so much over the years. Yeah. But let me get back to R Reginald George, though, this male male Regina George, because there's something else that he's doing about the dominance thing, which is interesting. Like, so this is weird, but go with me for a second. Like, if you you know, like you're hanging out with a bunch of guys, and maybe it's people you know well, maybe it's not, and you're you're just like, I don't know, joking around. Like, you know, the the social currency is that we're all making jokes, we're all making wise cracks, and there's kind of uh as that gets going and you're all hanging out together, everyone laughs at everyone's jokes a little bit.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_01Even some that you're like, nah, that wasn't particularly clever, but we're all just being friendly, so we're gonna laugh.
SPEAKER_02And then some jokes laughter as a as a sign of approval rather than I found this funny.
SPEAKER_01Exactly, exactly. And then there's also like the pickup, like someone makes a joke and it's so good that someone else like extends that joke and makes like an example of it. All right, this is what's so what's so interesting with this particular person. They are the kind of person that they will sit around and make jokes, and then other people make jokes, and they will sit there and be like, no, not funny. Like, and then when they make a joke, it's like almost this I like insistent eye contact of like, that was just the funniest joke. You all have to laugh. Yeah, exactly. But when everyone else says anything, it's just like no. Like, I'm gonna wait until I say the funny thing. Like, it's a weird way of like asserting this, like, I am the coolest person in this group right now.
SPEAKER_02You're not talking about me, are you? No. Okay, good. In that case, why are you still hanging out with this person?
SPEAKER_01Well, actually, it's funny because I we rarely sound kind of like a genghis. No, we just ran into the technical term. But that yeah, it actually. Um but but but it's just so interesting to see this dynamic play out, even though who the hell cares right now? Like what's you know, we would just sort away from that, but it's funny that these stuff, these things still creep in to our adults' interactions every now and again. And yeah, I'll probably not hang out with that person for at least a year until I find myself in a crowd and they happen to be there. But it makes me think about all the times that it's more subtle that I'm not even noticing it. That like, when when is someone doing this dominance thing? Or we don't even realize it. Yeah. Like, why am I acting like I am this person is more in control and they're holding open the door, or they're taking lead of the conversation.
SPEAKER_02Why? The holding the door bit is is interesting because I have back of my mind noticed that there is this kind of like subtle jostling for holding the door open as like a sign of I'm leading everyone in. And I haven't really like connected that to anything, but that's interesting. Yeah. That said, Dustin Hoffman holds the door open in the graduate, and that's a sign of his like subordination. So it's really like it's a contextual thing, too.
SPEAKER_01Once you start looking for ways that when guys are hanging out with other guys, there's some sort of uh I'm deferring to you. I'm I'm pointing out that you're somehow higher than me, if not physically than functionally, or I'm trying to pose as somehow being higher than you. Once you once you look for it, unless you're and yeah, I think your friends, my friends, like I don't think this happens very often, but but if you're in a crowd of of guys, especially if you don't know each other very well yet, I'm telling you it's there.
SPEAKER_02All right. It is absolutely there. Do you think, and I guess I should ask, to what extent do you think it's nature versus nurture? Because there, I mean, we're definitely like in a culture where guys are conditioned to actively pursue being the leader, the dominant one, et cetera. But you're connecting it with other species. So there's like a natural element to it today.
SPEAKER_01I mean, you know, we know evolutionarily that like when it comes to reproduction, and you know, it's the usually the more showy or the largest that can fend off, you know, others that is going to win the day. So there's like a whole survival. Like if you want your gene pool to propagate, like you are going to reward those that are the biggest or whatever. But I do think there's a nurture. I think from the day that we're born, there is some element. I mean, why do we pick presidential candidates based on their height? We don't even realize we're doing it, but I think we're doing it a little bit.
SPEAKER_02Like up to up to a point, right?
SPEAKER_01Up to a point. Like, why are we doing that? Because there's something about them being socialized to be more leader or us looking at them and saying they feel like a leader.
SPEAKER_02And it does have to be natural height too, because everyone makes fun of Ron DeSantis for wearing the lift. Oh my god. Well, right. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01No, it has to be, yeah, yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01There was just a movie about that, about the height lengthening. You can get this incredibly painful surgery, apparently, well, they'll break your legs, stick more bone in your legs, and then like you have to heal up and you can like grow four inches or something. But I suspect there are very few women getting that surgery. Uh I bet that that's predominantly males. Like again, I think there's something about this with guys.
SPEAKER_02But specifically with height. Like there is there is cosmetic surgery for women. It's just not a good thing. Oh, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01There's a whole bunch of hierarchies and dominance and issues, and the media has done a thousand times worse for women on physical appearance without question. I feel like we talk about some of those things a lot as a society, and we're doing a good job of starting to say, hey, not cool. Like we should be doing I don't know that we talk about this. I'm I'm not equating it as being just as bad, but I'm just saying, like, isn't it interesting? There's something influencing our behavior. Whether you're the person that just feels more like a leader, or you're the person that's deferring to there's something influencing us all around us just by standing up. And we're not talking about it, realizing it. And I think it's present in a lot of guy interactions.
SPEAKER_02Interesting. You know, my number one takeaway from this is gonna be the next time I'm standing in line at the coffee shop, I'm gonna like stand tall and crowd up against the person in front of me, and then no one's gonna walk in a room.
SPEAKER_01Don't crowd up. I'm crowding up.
SPEAKER_02People will know not to trifle with me.
SPEAKER_01Do the experiment. I swear it. Like it's so interesting. It's just, and then if you're a tall person, like try to de-heighten a little bit. Like, I just I swear it's so interesting. Like how there are these subtle things, and it happens all the time. Group of guys walking into a bar, who is the one holding the door? And it's just it's almost this. I don't want to say it's an emasculating thing because that's taking it too far, but like there is this element of like, why are you holding open the door? Like, that's usually what you would do for a woman. I was here first, I'm the one holding open the door. But now you've put your hand like over my head to hold the door and gestured for me to go in. Like, that's kind of funny.
SPEAKER_02That's why vestibules are so cool, because then the person who goes in second gets to hold open the door for everyone else.
SPEAKER_01That's right. Well, that's clearly the solution.
SPEAKER_02Let's the exchange of hierarchy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. We really need some psychology architects kind of, you know, collaborations, and then we'll solve all the world's problems.
SPEAKER_00This has been That Popular Podcast. Subscribe to us and find all our episodes wherever you get your podcasts, or visit us online at thatpopularpodcast.com.